Insurance Claims & Payments

To report a claim or to make a payment 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, contact the company your policy is placed with via the phone number or website shown below. If your carrier does not have a number listed, please contact our office during our normal business hours and we will be happy to assist you.

Business Phone Website
Foremost 800-527-3905 Visit website
National General 800-325-1190 Visit website
The Hartford 800-547-5000 Visit website
Mercury Insurance 800-503-3724 Visit website
Main Street America Group/ NGM Ins Co. 877-425-2467 Visit website
NYCM / A.Central 888-234-6926 Visit website
Preferred Mutual Ins Co 800-333-7642 Visit Website
Progressive Ins Co 800-776-4737 Visit Website
Safeco Ins Co 800-332-3226 Visit Website
Security Mutual 800-527-5000 Visit Website
Selective Insurance Co 800-455-9969 Visit Website
Travelers 877-878-2468 Visit Website
Utica National Ins Co 800-456-4556 Visit Website
Vermont Mutual Ins Co 800-451-5000 Visit Website